Government & PolicyPerson-Centred Care

As the Casey Commission continues its work towards a National Care Service, one question keeps resurfacing: is the system fair to everyone who relies on it? New research commissioned by the Social Care Institute for Excellence (SCIE) suggests the answer, for many, is no and the reasons why go far beyond simple differences in local provision.

An Unequal Burden of Work

The research, based on the experiences of people who draw on care and unpaid carers, found that accessing, securing, coordinating and sustaining social care demands vastly different amounts of effort depending on who you are. Disability, income, ethnicity, age, gender and where someone lives all shape how much work is involved in simply getting appropriate support.

Crucially, the study found these factors rarely operate in isolation. Geography, income, disability, ethnicity, digital exclusion and system complexity interact and accumulate, so that difficulties encountered early in someone’s care journey make every subsequent stage harder. A person who struggles to get clear information at the outset is often the same person left chasing updates, repeating their story to different professionals, and proving their need for support all over again months later.

Participants described this as a near-constant cycle of explaining circumstances, coordinating support and challenging decisions — experiences they associated with stress, frustration and fatigue rather than any single bad interaction.

Who Is Left to Cope Alone

The research points to a stark divide in who can absorb this workload. People with money, confidence, digital access, family advocacy or professional knowledge of the system are generally better placed to push through its demands and shape support around their own needs. Those without these advantages are more likely to accept unsuitable care, lean more heavily on unpaid carers, go without support entirely, or disengage from services altogether.

This unevenness carries an emotional cost that the research captures in some detail. Participants spoke of worrying whether they deserved care in the first place, of not wanting to burden family members or the wider system, and of fearing that support could be reduced or withdrawn without warning. Feeling misunderstood by services was a recurring theme.

What Good Care Actually Looks Like

Set against this, participants were consistent about what worked well: being listened to, being known as an individual, continuity in relationships, trust, and support genuinely shaped around their lives, preferences and goals. These relational qualities, more than any specific service model, were what people associated with feeling in control of their own care.

Gerard Crofton-Martin, Interim Chief Executive of SCIE, said the findings should inform how a future National Care Service is designed. “Our new research demonstrates that when it comes to care, choice and control are not experienced equally,” he said, adding that this leaves good-quality care out of reach for many people with unmet needs.

What Providers and Policymakers Can Take From This

Participants identified a consistent set of priorities that speak directly to providers as well as government: a named point of contact to help people navigate the system, greater continuity and consistency of carers, clearer and more proactive information about eligibility, better coordination and information-sharing between services, and greater use of trusted community organisations offering culturally and linguistically appropriate support. Investment in workforce pay, skills, stability and retention also featured heavily — a reminder that consistency for the person receiving care is inseparable from stability in the workforce delivering it.

For care providers, the research is a useful prompt to look at where in someone’s journey friction builds up at referral, at reassessment, at moments of transition and to consider how much of that burden could be reduced through better communication and continuity, rather than assuming it is solved once access has been granted.

The study, conducted by Thinks Insight & Strategy on behalf of SCIE, drew on interviews, focus groups and co-creation sessions with people drawing on care and unpaid carers across four local authority areas. SCIE says the findings will feed into its wider work supporting local services, strengthening co-production and shaping the case for a fairer, more consistent National Care Service.

Social Care Institute for Excellence logo
Featured in this article
Social Care Institute for Excellence
View profile

Privacy Preference Center